Pictures

Pictures

Friday, 17 March 2017

Review #1 Esmemade..
Please read my post Entitled "Writing Doll Reviews" before reading this review.....


My first handmade doll came from Esmemade. I found her through Instagram and immediately fell in love with her designs and just her art in general. She’s not just great at making some pretty original and creative dolls, she is also a pretty awesome painter and craftswoman. Plus she’s super nice and supportive of other artists. She is an all around awesome person. 



Ok, so now onto the actual doll. We did a trade for one of her Frida Kahlo dolls, she is pretty much my Idol and I am obsessed with her life, story, art and just her in general. I instantly fell in love with Esmeralda’s rendition of her and I was absolutely thrilled to be the one that got to call her my own. She has mainly been on display since last summer when I received her although my daughter does play with her from time to time. My dolls are all displayed in my studio but my five year old daughter can play with them as often as she likes as long as she is careful with them.



1. Description. 

So, I am going to start with a description of her. She is roughly 17’’ tall which is a really good size. Not too big, not too small and perfectly huggable. Her body is made with cotton, she is stuffed with polyester filling, her hair is organic jersey fabric in a deep eggplant purple. Her clothing is also jersey fabric and she has wool felt shoes, all pieces are removable including her maroon wrap around her shoulders. Her wool felt flowers are attached to her head as are her pom earrings. Her arms are button jointed and are thus posable/ movable. 

2. Does it look the same “In Real Life” as it did online?

Yes, she is just as lovely in person as she was pictured, if not more so as you can see more of the intricate embroidery work on her head much clearer in person. All colours were truly represented, as well as textures.
Was the product description accurate?
Yes, she was exactly as advertised, no unwanted surprises. 


3. Cost- On a scale of 1- Being very cheap to 10- “excuse me while I sell a kidney on the black market” 

The price of this beauty was $100 USD, she now makes smaller versions of the Frida doll (that are pictured below) and they are in the $40 US range. 

Esmeralda’s dolls are definitely on the lower end of the price scale. More affordable and thus more accessible to people. Most handmade dolls are around the $100 mark which is “pricey” to some but when you consider the amount of work that goes into a handmade doll or item compared to the mass produced and cheaply made products found in stores the price makes sense. 

I’d rate the price right at 4, the lower end of average. 

Would I say the cost matches the product?
Yes, however I do think that they might be slightly under-priced, meaning the maker could be charging more. Especially considering the amount of time and effort they take to make. 

4. Initial Reaction- 
I bought another doll along with the Frida (which I am not reviewing here), I received them pretty promptly, I don’t think it was more than 8 business days from when she sent it to when I received it. (The other doll is pictured below).

The packaging was nice, there was a business card in there as well as a hand written personalized card. Overall the presentation was nice, not over the top but nice. 

My initial reaction of the Frida doll was one of love. She is soft, lovely and peaceful, the colours are rich and I think she is a good representation of the real Frida. 

5. How well is it made?

Now I am going to delve a little deeper into the quality of the doll. Remember, these are handmade items, they are not going to be perfect, they are made by humans, not machines so there will be “imperfections” which I find often give the doll more character. But there is a difference between “imperfections” and poor craftsmanship. 

I’ll start with the body, the body is well sewn, her legs are sewn in to the body and it appears that she is stuffed from the head down as there is no visible seam around the body. She’s on the side of under stuffed but that is really a preference thing. I prefer firmly stuffed dolls and although she is slightly under stuffed (again- my preference) she is not floppy. The legs are the same, just slightly under stuffed, same with the arms. The arms are sewn up at the top, the stitches are visible and there are some fraying threads popping up. They are button jointed, the buttons match and they are firmly attached. Her organic fabric hair is a beautiful colour. It is hand sewn in place with a top braid. There are visible stitches at the back of the head as well as a small white knot that you can see. Her earrings are little fabric pom poms that are hand sewn in place, they are firmly attached. The wool felt flowers are hot glued in place and are also firmly attached. 
The embroidery on her face is very well done, the stitches are neat and skillfully done. 

Her clothes- Her skirt is made of jersey fabric, some of the seams/ hems are reinforced with a zig zag stitch. The hems are not 100% perfect but it is near impossible to get perfect seams on a stretchy jersey fabric. It has an elastic waist band and fits the doll very well, it’s not too baggy, it’s just right. Her shirt has some exposed edges and some loose threads, it is coming apart slightly at one seam. Her wool felt shoes are pretty much perfect. The seams are great, they are shaped well and fit perfectly. Her scarf/ shawl is a long rectangular piece of unfinished jersey fabric that can be styled on her in many ways. 

7. Level of skill displayed by the artist.

 I would say that this artist is fairly skilled. Her machine sewing and hand sewing show a good level of understanding and execution. Her embroidery work is excellent in my opinion. 
8. Display or Play? Is this doll best suited for display only or is it suited for young child play?
In her description it says that she is intended for display or gently supervised play. I would say that although she does have small parts (only the pom earrings) that she is tough enough to withstand play. She is not flimsy or delicate, I am not worried that my little one is going to damage her at all. She’s well made but considering the earrings, as they may pose a choking hazard in the hands of rambunctious toddlers, I’d say she’s best suited to children over four. 

9. “The Child Says” - Interview with my five year old about the doll,
after playing with her several times.

Do you like this Doll?
Yes!

What do you like the most about her?
Her hair with the flowers.

What don’t you like about her?
Nothing, I like kind of everything about her because she’s really pretty.

Was she fun to play with? 
Yes, a lot. 

What else do you want to say about her?
She’s really pretty, she has cool clothes, I like her earrings and I like that she looks like Frida Kahlo (my daughter is a huge Frida fan like me, we have books about her and she loves her art).

10. Originality- This is a very touchy subject. To be honest there are only so many ways to make dolls so many will share some design features. 

When it comes to Esmemade though, she’s got originality in the bag. 
Esmeralda’s designs are definitely unique, eclectic and interesting. Especially when it comes to her pumpkin headed dolls, mermen and Wednesday Adams dolls. She’s drumming to her own beat and we love what she’s throwing down. 







A little bit about the artist, how long she’s been making dolls and some of her other work. 

Esmeralda joined Instagram in April of 2014, she’s been crafting up dolls since she was a kid, of about 10. She then picked it up again when she was 22, she made a few bunnies and bears that were hand sewn and simple. After that is was when her daughter was born that she decided to dive deep into the world doll making and that was about two and a half years ago. In the past (almost) three years of her Instagram game her dolls have grown and developed as she has experimented with art and design. Her dolls have taken giant leaps in skill and originality, just look below at some of the amazing things she has come up with. 





She is also a very talented painter and her drawings are just as amazing. She’s got some mad skillz guys, she has magic in that mind of hers. 








Conclusion

Would I buy it again after seeing it “In Real Life”
Yes, absolutely, a million times over. Although this was a trade she is totally worth the price, but like I said, I think she should in fact be charging more for these beauties. 

Would I recommend this shop and her dolls?
Obviously yes, yes I would. 


Final Rating of the doll- On a scale of 1- Not that thrilled to middle ground 5- Average/ Pretty Darn Good to 10- Best thing I’ve seen in my life - I’d give this doll a 7. She’s original, beautiful and one of my favourites in my collection. 


Thanks for reading!! <3
Athena

Writing Doll Reviews

So, I decided to start reviewing dolls a little while ago. Not just because I have such a heart felt love for them, which I really do and not just because I have a large and growing collection but also because as a doll maker I have an inside perspective. I feel I can give a bit more insight to the functionality and quality of the items I’m reviewing. Also, I am going to be completely honest and I will try to be as unbiased as possible with my reviews. Doll making is a small community and it is not my intention to offend nor is it my intention to sell these products to you or anyone. None of these reviews are coerced by the maker, they are my opinion and my opinion alone. My husband was actually the one that suggested that I start reviewing the dolls I get since there was a lack of others doing reviews on them so there was a need for it and also because I make them myself so I am likely to have a good knowledge base for the aspects of the dolls that I am reviewing. 
I just want to through something out there regarding my own dolls. By reviewing others I am in no way trying to say that my dolls are perfect, or that they are in any way better or worse than any other dolls makers product out there. I have many ways to improve as I’ve kind of just started making dolls (since last May) but, I have been sewing, embroidering, etc. since I was very young. 

I am going to give you a bit of info on my background in the arts so that you can see where my thoughts (on the reviews) come from. I started hand sewing when I was five, I sewed tiny dresses for my barbies as well as small pillows for my dolls and friends. I started machine sewing as a young teen and even took classes in my later teens. I’ve sewn everything from my own clothing designs to home decor items and obviously dolls. I have been doing embroidery for over twenty years, not counting my childhood hand sewing of course, I have been crocheting for about thirteen years and I have been knitting for about four years (or so).I am also a felter, I began needle felting five years ago and wet felting four years ago. I have been teaching felting in all it’s forms locally for two and a half years, I have done dozens and dozens of classes with up to twenty people in a class. I am also a hand spinner, I clean/ process and dye all kinds of wool, alpaca, silk, etc. I’ve been spinning for four years and working in depth with wool for five. I have studied all the breeds of sheep and the ways that they felt and work differently. I have also studied alpaca, silk worms and all non protein fibres such as cotton, hemp, tencel (which is silk like and made of wood pulp) to rose fiber. There are so many interesting materials out there to spin and felt with. I also do some weaving, basically I like collecting hobbies or better yet I like collecting skills and knowledge. 

To me handmade means “Made with Love”. I think the most important thing about buying handmade is the craftsmanship (or crafts(wo)manship ;) ) .It’s not always the case that handmade means better quality but most often the person creating handmade items takes their time, they use quality materials and they work hard to bring their creativity to life in a well crafted item. There are a crazy amount of reasons to buy handmade though. By supporting local or small artists and craftsmen you are stimulating your local (or world) economy but more importantly you are keeping them doing what they love and making beautiful items for the world to enjoy. 

I was raised to believe in quality over quantity. My grandfather was a Mennonite and I was raised with a lot of respect for artists, farmers and people that put their all into their work. Making things well and putting yourself and your own design into your work has worth, in fact I think it is one of the most worth while things in this world. I still have the three handmade dolls that I was given as a child by my mother and grand mother (as well as the wooden bed and chair that came with them) and I cared for them as if they were real, I cherished and loved them, I still do. 

To me dolls aren’t just “toys” they are friends, they are comfort, they are healing and they make the people that like them really, really happy. Like a kid at Christmas, I’ve seen people’s faces light up, eyes twinkling like stars in the nights sky and it is beautiful to behold. No matter how old we get there is still that kid inside of us, full of magic, wonder and vulnerability. It is sacred and should be acknowledged and nurtured in any way that is healing and good. 

The dolls that I have collected make me super happy. I have heard people say that collecting handmade dolls is addictive and this is SO true. 


I started out with just wanting to trade with some other doll makers, I admired their work so much and I absolutely LOVE bartering so I reached out and contacted some makers and most were extremely friendly and totally into the idea. I’ve made a ton of awesome maker friends through Instagram and I am super grateful to have these dolls that not only make me happy and brighten my day but they are reminders of these awesome ladies and the friendships I’ve made.

So there it is, my reasons for writing these reviews as well as a little bit of info about my crafting background.
Hope you enjoyed reading this :D

Athena